Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: The Infuriating Jose Molina

Did the New York Jets cheat? Should the league investigate?

Double Standard?
Jets Accused of 'Cheating'

Turns out the Patriots aren't the only ones.

Wow. I'm shocked.

For the benefit of Colts fans:
Disclaimer: Before anyone accuses me of trying to excuse Bill Belichick and the New England Patriots, the following is a philosophical discussion for which I am soliciting feedback from the Pats Pulpit community regarding the topic of cheating.

Baltimore Ravens head coach Brian Billick accused the New York Jets defense of using "illegal" tactics to trick Baltimore's offense into committing false start penalties. The Ravens did jump several times during the game.

So what of it? Is this a double standard?

A story at NFL.com doesn't describe the Jets' activity at cheating. Of course, the NFL never called Belichick or the Patriots cheaters either.

Star-divide

I've already heard that it's not a big deal because "the Jets didn't cheat to the extent the Patriots cheated." This comes from many of the same people who have said, "cheating is cheating" and demanded outrageously excessive punishments for Belichick and the Patriots.

I've also heard that "this is just a rule" and should be penalized on the field, as is provided in the rulebook. Well, prohibiting videotaping on the sideline is "just a rule too."

I've also read and heard plenty about the videotaping and whether in-game analysis could impact the game in progress. There's absolutely no debate that simulating snap signals has an immediate impact on the game in progress.

The game officials could have and should have called penalties on the Jets, but it's still cheating. Just the same as the Colts offensive linemen grabbing handfuls of jerseys and getting away with it. "Cheating is cheating," is it not?

Whether the Jets "cheated" should be easy to prove. There are enough field-level cameras and microphones to provide the evidence the league needs.

For the Patriots sins against humanity, they have already paid the price; yet they continue to be vilified. Other cheaters? Well, the Jets are 0-2, and no one seems to care.

Poll
Should the league treat all cheating the same?
Yes. All cheating is the same.
65 votes
No. There are shades and levels of cheating.
30 votes

95 votes | Poll has closed

Comment 3 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

This "cheating" is also something
that most teams probably engage in. This is more an indictment of Mangini by Billick for breaking the unwritten rules about snitching on your fellow coaches. Mangini can probably expect more of the same from most other coaches in the NFL who I believe are on Belichick's side (except for Tony Dungy who obviously has his own agenda that he advances on the competition committee).

by scsatr on Sep 18, 2007 8:29 PM EDT reply actions  

well since you asked
I don't consider what the Pats did to be cheating either. They broke a rule, yes, but cheating no. Did what the Pats did have an effect the actual game being played? No.

Did what the Jets did affect the actual game being played? Yes.

Cheating takes place on every down. Sometimes you get away with it, sometimes you don't.

At least in the end, the Jets lost the game.

by mrbandw on Sep 18, 2007 10:23 PM EDT reply actions  

Mangini is a Pharisee
and I'm glad to see him exposed as such.

Alot of coaches didn't appreciate what he did, and they'll let him have it.

by Ring4forFoxborough on Sep 21, 2007 12:12 AM EDT reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

A New England Patriots Blog

Media requests: Please email patspulpit at gmail.com


Managing Editor

Patriot_small Greg Knopping

Assistant Editor

Belichick_2_small Marima

Headshotoj_small Richard Hill

Dscn0127_small Jared Stegall

Contributing Writers

Photo_small Austin Martin

Small Stephen Verman

Bill-belichick_small Ashto12

Peter-heisman_small Alec Shane

Moderators

Kiwi_small Comedic.Sans

A-clockwork-orange-alex_small Jack'sAxe