Is Spygate still a relevant discussion?
I hesitate to write about Spygate because I feel like I'm simply feeding the wheel, providing extraordinary measures when there's already a DNR in place. However, going through Marima's links this morning, one story in particular grabbed my attention: Tim Graham's AFC East mailbag. The following question and response caught my eye:
Jamal from Facebook is sick of all the Patriots haters -- obviously fixated on Spygate as the excuse for everything the club has accomplished -- who post in the comments section under the AFC East blog posts.
I wholeheartedly agree, Jamal. Some fans will latch onto anything that helps them justify why their favorite teams haven't had the same success. Officiating conspiracies are good for that, too.
I kept an open mind about the Spygate saga as it developed, but I've spoken to more than enough intelligent football people about it. I'm convinced the benefits of the verboten video were overblown.
ESPN analyst Herm Edwards is one of the discerning minds I've asked about it. Edwards, then the New York Jets' head coach, was so unimpressed he was captured waving to the Patriots' camera in one of the illegal tapes from 2004.
"If you're naïve to believe that helped him win a Super Bowl," Edwards said last week, "you're kidding yourself. I don't believe that."
The key here is fan and intelligent football people. As Graham states, in the face of overwhelming evidence during a fan interaction, a rivals "trump" card is, "Well, the Patriots cheated and deserve an asterisk next to everything they've done." Uhhmm...ok. However, if you look through statements like that of Herm Edwards', you will find intelligent football people saying it didn't make a difference, that it's ludicrous to think Belichick and his players benefitted enough from taping to win Super Bowls. So, if football people don't think it made a difference, who does?
Again, I give you the rival fan. I've had enough conversations about this that they're almost scripted:
Me: four trips to the Super Bowl in eight seasons, three rings, record breaking 2007 season, lose starting QB in 2008 along with many other starters and almost take the division.
Rival: Oh Yeah?!?! Well, Belichick cheated so there's an asterisk next to everything. That's the only way he can win.
Me: What about 2007?
Rival: Yeah, but you LOST the Super Bowl!!!! PWNED CHEATERS!!
Me: Ok, this is going to be a two part answer, so try to keep up. a) How many teams made it to the Super Bowl and b) was your team one of them?
Rival: Uhhmm...yeah but Spygate...
Me: (cue Jeopardy music) I'm waiting...
Rival: (Now drooling, sputtering about how his maternal grandfather wouldn't give him a root beer barrel when he was three).
Me: Is that all you got? Spygate?!?! I feel like I'm in a fight with an unarmed man.
In the face of overwhelming evidence from people who REALLY know what they're talking about, rival fans still cling to this last desperate argument to justify why their team is simply not as good as the Patriots. It's weak and lazy. And it's a conversation ender. If a rival fan is not willing to move past this weak excuse for the Patriots' dominance, there's not much more that can be discussed.
So, given intelligent football people have dismissed Spygate as the reason for the Patriots' success, is this largely a fan driven controversy? Does the media play a part in it, too? What do the Patriots have to do to prove, without a doubt, they are the best football team of this decade?
19 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
9ers fan for life but Love the Pats in the AFC
They just remind me of the old 9ers teams that were so dominant w/ Montana(Brady although he needs 1 more ring) and Rice(Moss, but don’t get it twisted. Rice is one of the best football players ever). To get on subject I think talking about Spygate is as irrellevent as talking about the Steelers of the 70’s roiding like crazy. Who cares anymore. You still have to play the game. I take the 2002 Super Bowl of the Raiders vs. Bucs for example. The Bucs new every play the Raiders were calling. But they still had to stop em right? You still have to play the game. I think the Roid issue in the 70’s had a larger effect on football than video taping a game or practice. In actual gameplay, a lot of players especially the vets know before the snap what the offense is calling or planning to do because they can read the formations and they study nonstop. That’s all gravey but you still have to execute and stop them. You can video tape all day and all night but you still have to execute.
Fans stuck in the 80's are lame. Respect the past, live in the now.
Steeler fans especially are hilariously clueless
The recent off-season discussion of ’Who’s the best team of the decade" exposed the typical Steeler fan in denial who is convinced Pittsburgh is really the best team of the decade because they didn’t win their Super Bowls by cheating (although more than a few Seahawks fans still swear they certainly had the blessing of the officials.)
Are the fans truly that hypocritical that they can dismiss or deny the effect of the “Steroid Curtain” defense in winning those championships of the 70’s? Is videotaping from a location different from what is allowed by the league an equal or greater violation of NFL rules than rampant blatant steroid use, prescribed by the team’s own physician? At the very least, Steeler Nation should keep it’s collective mouth shut.
Keep the faith!
Seahawks
I am one of that feels the Steelers had the officials in their corner big time in SB40. And i hate the Seahawks too but they got ripped off! And you can ask me who the team of the decade is and I’ll tell you straight up that it’s the Pats. Anyone saying otherwise is a moron.
Fans stuck in the 80's are lame. Respect the past, live in the now.
Steelers fan are beginning to remind me of the 90's
when you had all of these idiots saying they were Cowboys fans. It’s like “Shut your face” you just bought that stupid puffy Cowboys jacket cuz they won the SB for the 3rd time. Alot of Steelers fans like that now too. You;d think there would be more people like that for the Pats but there aren’t. Not like the Cowboys and Steelers.
Fans stuck in the 80's are lame. Respect the past, live in the now.
Good to be a 9ers fan the last 7 years...
only bc all of the fairweather fans got weeded out quickly. Now it’s time to take the division back.
Fans stuck in the 80's are lame. Respect the past, live in the now.
I've thought it was irrelevant soon after it's conception.
There was a recent article posted on this website which was basically a former NFL player stating that teams do and have done much worse to get a competitive advantage over opposing teams. In other words, they’d cheat.
The Patriots were just exposed. Used as a way to fool the rest of the country into thinking that this ‘cheating’ isn’t tolerated. Anyone who thinks all professional sports are ‘pure’ or without some form of ‘cheating’ then you’re kidding yourself. And it’s not just one team or player doing it. As previously mentioned, these athletes have to go out and actually play the game. Not justifying ‘cheating’ but just highlighting the fact that it takes more to win games and titles.
But we rarely hear from the educated, non-ESPN message board posters, who understand the reality of professional football. It’s almost always the loud ‘18-1 SPYGATE CHEATRIOTS WWAAAHHHH’ fans that seem to be more vocal.
Other ways to get an advantage
Look around the league and see how many players are traded within each division the reason is three-fold:
1) They see the competitors more and therefore have more info on them.
2) Taking a good player who gives you problems (Wes Welker) from a competitor (Dolphins) makes them weaker and you stronger.
3) They give you info on the opposition. They are expected to spill their guts and they do.
Every team does it and it is cheating, but it is legal
by SlotMachinePlayer on Jun 22, 2009 11:06 PM EDT reply actions
Its ok..
WE shut them up once we rattled off 18 games in a row and should have been 19.. But thats ok we went out and won everyone of those games with everyone watching.. But it was still cheating somehow we still cheated even though we did it with everything being looked at through a microscope. It was funny and enjoyable to watch and to shut up the cry babies. I hope this yr we do what they say is the impossible.. Rattle off and finish what we began that yr and go 19-0.. It will silence all those idiots that say we cheat and if not well… Then at least we can laugh in their faces and truly cement it in concrete as the team of the decade.. Even though i already believe that it is already proven…
I know one intelligent football person who thought they were getting an advantage.
If Hoodie didn’t thing it was giving him an advantage, why did he break the rules? Because if it gave him an advantage on only two or three plays a game, he still wanted that advantage. Who knows when a critical play will turn a game? If Hoodie had the advantage on one of those plays, he wanted it. And since we don’t really know which plays they received an advantage on it is an impossible argument to prove or disprove.
The signals are out in public.
Anyone can see them, so whether you’re videotaping them or copying them down, you are still achieving the same result. There is no “spying” as the name Spygate implies. Teams also change their signals up all the time, even at the half.
Give it a rest.
Don't muddy a good spy story with the truth
The spygate scandal allowed everyone to collectively forget that these defensive signals are clearly visible during the game without the aid of a camera. In fact the assignment of every ‘clipboard carrying’ number 3 QB was to gather and record that information during the game. That was his JOB on the sideline. Belilchick just made the process more efficient like he does everything else in his life, but he didn’t get any new or different information than any other coach could have had.
Keep the faith!
Strangely enough, I’ve never heard anyone drive that point home – that there wasn’t any ‘spying’ in Spygate yet it’s title suggests it’s the sleaziest, most unprofessional act ever the happen in the NFL.
Spygate is over
And I really think we can see it in perspective now. Of course the Patriots benefited somewhat from it – or they thought they did – otherwise they wouldn’t have taken the time and effort to do the filming.
Was it instrumental in making the Patriots a great team? No, it takes a hell of a lot more than that. Maybe some game, somewhere was won because of it, but there is really no way of knowing it.
And that is of course the annoying thing. Patriots fans can forever say, that it didn’t matter at all, and other teams can claim that it did, and there is no way of stopping it, because at the end of the day, we just don’t know how much it meant. If people just yells CHEATERS!! all the time, it just gets boring, which is why the ESPN boards are mostly a waste of time. Lots of trashtalking and people yelling at eachother without any exchange of ideas.
Now, the Patriots’ success had a lot more to with talent, coaching, execution and – let’s face it – luck than it had to do with cheating, but there is just no way around the fact that they were caught with their hands in the cookie jar. They DID cheat. Others may have done the same or something worse, but it doesn’t change the fact: They did cheat.
As a fan, you don’t stop loving your team because they cheat, much like you don’t stop loving your children if they are caught shoplifting or care for your friends if they are pulled over for DUI. But it does change the way you see them. How could it not? I still admire Belichick and the Patriots for what they accomplished but of course I see them differently after Spygate. But that is the point about caring, really caring, about something. You got to embrace it all.
Spygate
was about the biggest farce in league history. Never has there been such a big deal made about nothing.
by BabeParilli on Jun 23, 2009 5:19 AM EDT reply actions 1 recs
Herm Edwards
Please dont call Herm Edwards intelligent football people. The guy was never a CO before becoming a HC. He took over two playoff teams and ran them into the ground.
As for whether taping helped the Pats at all, nobody knows. One play can turn a game, remember the Jets BS TD against Seattle a while back on the last play of the game that earned them a playoff spot and cost Seattle one? It also ushered in the vidoe review. Im no football expert but Im assuming the NFL didnt make a rule that served no purpose. To say that NE success came from video taping is foolish. No doubt a talented team with a great coach. The question is did the vidoe tape every help them on say only one play in a playoff game ? Nobody will ever know
Fair point about Herm
I think the key Tim Graham quote is:
I’ve spoken to more than enough intelligent football people about it. I’m convinced the benefits of the verboten video were overblown
I’m assuming he means not just Herm. True, we’d need Graham’s list of “intelligent football people” to make a judgement, but I think the point is there’s far less noise about this from football insiders than from fans. Also true, it could be those football insiders simply circling the wagons.
Blogger at SBNation's Patriots blog, Pats Pulpit
STEELERS ARE THE BEST NFL FRANCHISE OF THE PAST 40 YEARS
The Pats are johnny-come-latelies in the long history of the NFL. The Steelers are the Big Dogs. They have history, tradition, a loyal single family ownership. The pontificating Pats fans are jealous of the tradition of the Black and Gold. Understandable indeed. STEELERS=First team to win four Superbowls. First team to win Six Superbowls. STEELERS=a successful organization=Six Superbowls with THREE different coaches. STEELERS=One family ownership
All jealous Pats fans are really . . . Belichick Fans. Also, Belichick is a great coach. The Franchise is not. Disagree? Check the win lost record since King Chuck Noll took over the Steelers and therefore, the NFL in 1968. The Pats are not even in the same league. The BELICHICK PATRIOTS are a great team, no doubt about it. The I-WISH-HAD-A-CITY PATRIOTS are NOT a great Franchise. The record speaks the truth. Sorry chumps. Get a City to back your team, win six superbowls, and improve you win-loss record, then the Beiichick Patriots might become a real team of destiny.
ps Most Pats fan are not Jealous, only those who try to ignore history and facts, and try to attack the big dogs because the Pats have had a good run this decade. That is a kid’s perspective. Again, a Belichick’s team is very good.

by 






























