Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Tiger Woods Makes His 2012 PGA Tour Debut

Running through the roster: thoughts on Mike Reiss's choices for the New England Patriots 53

There's a lot to be stoked about, dontcha think?  Belichick has so far done a masterful job of balancing the workload during training.  But what would you expect of the best NFL coach of the past decade?  Genius has become a hallmark, it's that simple.  The bar has been set incredibly high from the start.  While it might be taxing on all players and Belichick could run the risk of wearing out his players, the cream will rise to the top.

It is ridiculously early to begin predicting the final 53 man roster.  Insanely early, if you ask me.  But that won't stop The Boston Globe's Mike Reiss from taking a shot at it.  Nor will it stop me from analyzing what he has to say. ;-)

Star-divide

Looking down the list, I thought I could find some rhyme or reason as to the order of players in each category, but I was stymied.  Tom Brady, Kevin O'Connell, Andrew Walter - Hah!!  Alphabetical order!  But then there's Chris Baker, Ben Watson, David Thomas, and Alex Smith.  How about starting order?  Yeah, that's the ticket!  Oh, running backs: Kevin Faulk, Fred Taylor, Sammy Morris, Laurence Maroney, and BenJarvus Green-Ellis.  There goes that theory.  Anyway, enough fussing over the order of positional listing.

Commentors for this Reiss's Pieces blog post were saying Mike was a bit off when he said BenJarvus Green-Ellis should stay at the expense of another offensive lineman.  I won't necessarily address that, but I WOULD say keeping BJGE is a smart move.  Why?  He showed some skills last year.  Remember 2008, when the backfield was decimated enough to have Law Firm as one of our primary backs and Kevin Faulk running something other than third downs?  Yeah, we were hurtin'.  And the young dude was there.  Is he the future of this franchise's backfield?  I don't know if I can answer that question, but I DO know he did a darn good job for us.

Other than that, Mike's analysis seems pretty solid at this point.  Russ Hochstein is a keeper, in my mind.  Heck, the dude can not only play offensive line, but he can do a fair job at fullback.  Belichick loves versatility and this doesn't hurt.  WR-wise, one could make a case for Joey Galloway not making the cut, but let's give him a chance; it's pretty hard to walk onto a high-powered aerial assault like this and make a name for yourself.  Julian Edelman?  C'mon, the dude would have to have a core meltdown to goof up his spot.

Looking at Reiss's roster list gets me all fired up.  Wow, that looks good.

Poll
How was Mike Reiss's 53?
Spot on
58 votes
Not too shabby, but I'd make some changes
97 votes
Are you daft?
13 votes

168 votes | Poll has closed

Comment 7 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

Seems about right

all those guys are the best in each spot but the safty Mcgowan might not make it for Slater as he ruturns and plays safty or Ray-Vatrone one of those will make it

by Patsfan4life on Aug 16, 2009 9:01 PM EDT reply actions  

Cuts not listed

The problem with Reiss’ piece is not listing those cut.

WR looks nice – but in entails cutting Terrence Nunn and keeping Aiken

O-line looks ok, but i means giving up on O’Callaghan, Britt and other tested backups. Vollmer and Ohrnberger better be ready to step in if we keep only 8.

Safety – are we ready to give up on Tank Williams?

The good thing, though, is that we have too many good players, not too few.

by hythlodaeus on Aug 17, 2009 3:38 AM EDT reply actions  

so far

Aiken looks good (Nunn does too and I like him a lot, but Aiken still looks good)

Tank Williams has had the weakest camp so far for the safeties, surprising since I was really optimistic about him. McGowan has been interesting to watch. I’ve checked out his number a lot wondering who it was. Tank, I’ve barely noticed involved in anything.

It’s all a gamble at this point, but you’re right about it being good to have a choice. At least we’re not still desperately looking to fill a particular position.

Keep the faith!

by Marima on Aug 17, 2009 7:08 AM EDT up reply actions  

Thanks

Good input. If Nunn can be sneaked on the practice squad that’s great. And of course, injuries can change this a few times before season.

by hythlodaeus on Aug 17, 2009 7:43 AM EDT up reply actions  

Law Firm

I’m still baffled why people are rating BenJarvus Green-Ellis over Sammy Morris. Morris was a fantastic contributor last year, best of the RBs and a good counterpoint to Kevin Faulk. BenJarvus Green-Ellis was useful, but nowhere near as capable. I just don’t see how people are rating the latter as a replacement for Morris. If Morris was nicked up or had off the field issues, maybe, but there aren’t even hints of that.

by Comedic.Sans on Aug 17, 2009 5:46 AM EDT reply actions  

Faulk

Was the surprise for me. I suppose nothing should surprise me about him anymore, though. Until Maroney can go without hurting himself, it’s Taylor and Faulk… although I suppose Maroney would make a good 3rd down RB.

by Hardscores on Aug 17, 2009 10:40 AM EDT reply actions  

RB order

maroney
morris
taylor
faulk
bjge

by patriotguy on Aug 17, 2009 1:00 PM EDT reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

A New England Patriots Blog

Media requests: Please email patspulpit at gmail.com

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Small
Who Stays? Who Goes?
Super-bowl-ring_small
The Front Rank
Patriots-_haters_gonna_hate_small
Stop Starting Brady
Kitten_small
OTA - Off-Topic Activities #16: Where Peyton is our favorite Manning
Small
Intangibles for consideration:

Recent FanPosts

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Managing Editor

Patriot_small Greg Knopping

Assistant Editor

Belichick_2_small Marima

Headshotoj_small Richard Hill

Contributing Writers

Photo_small Austin Martin

Small Stephen Verman

Bill-belichick_small Ashto12

Peter-heisman_small Alec Shane

Moderators

Kiwi_small Comedic.Sans

Amd_mccourty2_small UtopianAverage