Patriots Game Ratings: Week 1 vs. Dolphins
Here at Pats Pulpit, we're going to be introducing a new "game ratings" feature for Patriots players every week during the 2011 season. In these ratings, I will select several players per game, and assign them ratings on a -3 to +3 scale, with "0" constituting an average performance. Here is my "scale" for the performances:
-3: The player had a performance to forget, and significantly hurt his team on the field.
-2: The player had a couple of bad mistakes, or a well below average performance.
-1: The player performed below average, or below what we've come to expect for that player.
0: The player had an average performance, or a performance that is expected of that player.
+1: The player had a good performance, helping to positively impact his team on the field.
+2: The player made multiple impact plays that helped shape the game's outcome.
+3: The player was a difference maker on the field, playing at an elite level throughout.
Something to keep in mind: These are all subjective ratings. These are my personal evaluations and aren't based on any statistical formulas or anything such as that. They are simply my evaluations based on what I saw on the field. That being said, lets get started with our week one "Patriots Game Ratings":
Tom Brady, QB, #12: +3 (Season: +3)
This week, it's easy to throw Tom Brady into the +3 category. From the onset of the game, Brady was hitting on all cylinders. He had all day to throw, and made the most of his opportunities. He spread the ball evenly, and was accurate on all levels of the field. A career day for one of the greatest NFL quarterbacks of all time.
Chad Ochocinco, WR, #85: -2 (Season: -2)
Chad had a day to forget. He was the team's third receiver behind Deion Branch and Wes Welker, and only managed 18 snaps. He had just one grab for 14 yards in the game, and had a five yard illegal formation penalty that cost the team a 41 yard gain on a Brady-to-Gronkowski pass.
Deion Branch, WR, #84: +1 (Season: +1)
Deion Branch received some criticism throughout the preseason for not performing, as he failed to record a single reception. However, once the regular season kicked off, Branch was super-involved in the Patriots offense, making seven grabs for 93 yards, looking impressive on his routes in the process. I guess chemistry really does pay off.
Nate Solder, T, #77: +2 (Season: +2)
When news that Sebastian Vollmer would miss the season opener against the Dolphins and that rookie tackle Nate Solder would get the start hit late last week, there were some mixed emotions in Patriots Nation. Fortunately for the Patriots and fans alike, Solder had a memorable performance going against one of the NFL's most feared pass rushers in Cameron Wake. I'm not sure when Solder will get his next chance to start, but his play in the opener was certainly an encouraging sign.
More Patriots game ratings after the jump!
Gary Guyton, LB, #59: -2 (Season: -2)
Gary Guyton had a rough night. On the opening drive, he failed to stop the run and was out of position against the pass on multiple occasions. He was replaced throughout the night by Dane Fletcher, who seemed to have out-performed him. Guyton is a solid player who should benefit more from being in the 4-3.
Ras-I Dowling, CB, #21: +1 (Season: +1)
Dowling had a solid performance on the outside, especially when factoring in the fact that it was the career debut for the 2nd round pick. Dowling was physical, fast, and shut down multiple throws in the end zone. He also did a good job handling Brandon Marshall.
Devin McCourty, CB, #32: -1 (Season: -1)
Devin McCourty didn't have a terrible game by any stretch of the imagination. Still, his performance was a bit up and down and it left a little to be desired. McCourty came up with two pass break-ups and a near interception, but he was also targeted very frequently, which is never a good sign for a cornerback. I'm sure he'll bounce back next week.
Rob Gronkowski, TE, #87: +2 (Season: +2)
Rob Gronkowski had a great all-around night for the Patriots on Monday. He was excellent as an inline blocker, red zone threat, and was impossible to cover down the seam. Gronk finished the night with six receptions for 86 yards and a touchdown.
Aaron Hernandez, TE, #81: +2 (Season: +2)
Like his counterpart Rob Gronkowski, Aaron Hernandez also had a night to remember for the Patriots on Monday. He was second on the team in receptions and yards (7 for 103), and also added a touchdown. Hernandez played all over the field, and was essentially the team's third receiver.
Wes Welker, WR, #83: +3 (Season: +3)
Before the season began, I predicted that Patriots receiver Wes Welker would return to his 2009 form in 2011. In the season opener, Welker recorded 160 yards on eight catches for a pair of touchdowns. His 99 yard reception from Tom Brady in the fourth quarter will be remembered for a long time.
Stephen Gostkowski, K, #3: -1 (Season: -1)
Gostkowski missed a very makeable 48 yard field goal in the second quarter. The kick went wide right, and wasn't even close.
Matt Light, T, #72: +1 (Season: +1)
Light did have one penalty, but had a really unheralded performance protecting Tom Brady's blind side Monday night. Good start to the season for the veteran.
Matthew Slater, WR, #18: +1 (Season: +1)
Slater made his first career reception on a diving 46 yard bomb from Tom Brady on the Patriots' opening drive. It's a feel-good story, and it was the culmination of a lot of hard work. On a side-note, Slater could actually be a key to the Patriots deep attack this year. He looked impressive throughout training camp and the preseason as a receiver.
Albert Haynesworth, DL, #92: +1 (Season: +1)
Haynesworth played limited snaps, but seemed to make the most of his opportunities. He came up with a couple of nice run stops and also came up with a pair of quarterback pressures.
Mark Anderson, DE, #95: +1 (Season: +1)
Anderson impressed as a pass rusher in sub-packages, and he seems to have taken on the role as "designated speed rusher" for the Patriots in 2011. He also came up with a sack late in the game.
Pat Chung, SS, #25: +1 (Season: +1)
Chung proved yet again why he is one of the Patriots most valuable defenders on Monday night. He was all over the field, coming up with nine tackles and a sack. He was solid in coverage and even had a big time hit on Anthony Fasano in the open field (a very clean shoulder hit I might add).
Dan Connolly, C/G, #63: +1 (Season: +1)
When Dan Koppen went down with an ankle injury late in the second quarter, jack-of-all trades reserve Dan Connolly stepped into the center position and made the transition seemingly seamless. Great game from Connolly.
Brian Waters, G, #54: +1 (Season: +1)
Waters, with the team for less than a week, moved into the starting lineup at right guard for the Patriots immediately, having not taken part in training camp for any team. Overall, he performed quite well. He also played more snaps than expected, as he played every remaining snap once Dan Koppen went down, forcing Connolly to exclusively play center (and eliminating the possibility of rotating him in).
34 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Out of curiousity
I’m assuming you’re evaluating performance vs expectation, and not performance relative to some kind of replacement level benchmark?
Yes, expectation does have an impact
So you can’t exactly compare players using this subjective system. You couldn’t, well Jerod Mayo is performing at a +3 for the year, and Ras-I Dowling is at +6 so Dowling is the better player. But you could say, that based on what we’ve come to expect from Mayo, Dowling seems to have a comparatively better season.
Likewise, this week, Matt Light was the better overall player than Matthew Slater. However, based on this rating system, they both grade out equally.
by Greg Knopping on Sep 15, 2011 4:51 PM EDT up reply actions
Odd lack of 0s...
Or did everyone who wasn’t called out for a ranking earn a 0?
"You wanna know which ring is my favorite? The next one." --Tom Brady
Yes.
I didn’t feel a need to post a “0” score. If the player isn’t represented above, that player received a “0.”
But remember, a zero isn’t a negative thing. That means that the player performed up to par with what we would expect from them. Jerod Mayo didn’t play particularly bad, but he didn’t play above what we would expect from him either. Therefore, there wasn’t a need to mention him.
This post is essentially a more in-depth up/down scale for the game. I thought putting a quantitative number would make it a little more fun to debate.
If people do not prefer this method, I can go back to the usual “stock report” for the remainder of the season.
by Greg Knopping on Sep 15, 2011 6:36 PM EDT up reply actions
So can TB earn anything between a +3 and a -1?
I mean, he’s either elite or he’s below expectations (or worse)…
by CelticPride on Sep 16, 2011 10:01 AM EDT up reply actions
Hmm...
If you’re expecting him to get, say, 250 yards and two TDs… Then maybe an extra TD is +1, an extra 100 yards is also a +1.
So 500 yards plus 4 TDs (-1 int) would come to say, +3. That works
Token southern hemisphere guy - 14,688km from Foxboro. That's 9128 miles, for you heathens.
Contributing Writer at PatsPulpit
by Comedic.Sans on Sep 16, 2011 10:16 AM EDT up reply actions
Good reasoning
In GOD I TRUST>In BB i trust......faith where it belongs!!
Life is about who makes it, not who makes it the fastest! Drive slow homie.
by PatNation85 on Sep 16, 2011 12:45 PM EDT up reply actions
Slater
I was impressed by the long grab. I’m really hoping for Taylor Price to make a big impact, maybe a la Jabar Gaffney, as a #3 or #4 receiver. But if he doesn’t and Slater does, that’s still good for the team.
Also Solder really impressed me on Wake.
McCourty may have been disappointing. But only because we all expect him to be the next Revis, or even better than Revis, because of the season he had last year. And actually I still think McCourty will have a great season, and ultimately end up slightly improving on last year.
I’ve long admired and defended Guyton. He looked straight terrible. He made me look really bad.
so YOU jinxed him!
"There's no place like it, and it's ours." - Stephen King on Fenway Park
by 808BostonSportsFan on Sep 15, 2011 6:23 PM EDT up reply actions
i agree with most of this.
McCourty was up and down. I remember him making a few great plays, while getting beat on some. By a normal CB standard he would have been good, but from what we saw last year we expect him to be more than a normal CB; more in the top 5 range.
Also on Slater, while i was impressed by his first grab, he also missed a pretty catch able long pass later on by brady. So he still has some work to do.
Cool rating system
I like the rating system because it’s kind of like the highlight reel. Top players that stood out and had a great game and which ones really didn’t and maybe had a not so great game. Creative.
Good to hear. Any other thoughts on the series?
This seems like something that could be fun to track throughout the year.
by Greg Knopping on Sep 15, 2011 7:55 PM EDT up reply actions
Yes will be fun to track throughout the year.
I like +3 system and -3 system, but what about special contributions…like Brady’s game this week or Patrick Chung’s game last year (I think?) where he made amazing play on punt, kick return, interception, sack, etc. sort of like the full cycle in baseball. Maybe could have a special +5 for those sort of career days?
Nink's two-pick, one sack game vs Dolphins a 3, 4, 5?
Token southern hemisphere guy - 14,688km from Foxboro. That's 9128 miles, for you heathens.
Contributing Writer at PatsPulpit
by Comedic.Sans on Sep 17, 2011 1:23 AM EDT up reply actions
Jets fan here
Hi, Jets fans here. I must say that Tom Brady is the best QB I have ever seen. If he was our QB, it would be over. BUT, alas, we have Sanchez, and hopefully he’ll continue to improve, though probably never going to be a Brady. I love reading AFC East blogs, to get different perspectives, and I read what you expect of McCourty. Don’t get me wrong, he is very good, but he wont be Revis. Revis is a freak of nature, ala Brady. Just be happy that you have a great young corner, and a great team. See you in the playoffs, and good luck.
Thanks man
We do have high expectations for McCourty, and I don’t know that he’ll ever be a true shutdown corner, but he does a pretty good impersonation of one at times. The best example is probably the Lions game from last year where he collected 2 INTs while covering Calvin Johnson most of the game. At the very least, he is the best cover CB on the team, and having him allows the defense to do more with other plays since he often doesn’t need help on his assignment.
Good luck to you guys as well. I’m looking forward to week 5.
Deep in enemy territory
McCourty is definitely not revis now.
imo, he is a very good cover corner though.
I’ll take 11 players with heart on the field over 11 guys with just talent. Talent is fleeting, it goes away over time. Heart is what drives you to be better. To push yourself beyond what you think your capabilities are. To show us that when you strive, all things are possible.- SMP
Jack, should i start Keller against the Jags or Dickson against Tennessee?
In GOD I TRUST>In BB i trust......faith where it belongs!!
Life is about who makes it, not who makes it the fastest! Drive slow homie.
by PatNation85 on Sep 15, 2011 11:04 PM EDT up reply actions
dickson
Arizona Diamondbacks: 87-63
New England Patriots: 1-0
by freeland1787 on Sep 16, 2011 9:52 AM EDT up reply actions
Thanks bro!
In GOD I TRUST>In BB i trust......faith where it belongs!!
Life is about who makes it, not who makes it the fastest! Drive slow homie.
by PatNation85 on Sep 16, 2011 12:44 PM EDT up reply actions
Hi there. Thanks.
You have a very appropriate screen name.
"There's no place like it, and it's ours." - Stephen King on Fenway Park
by 808BostonSportsFan on Sep 15, 2011 9:03 PM EDT up reply actions
I get very annoyed
when I read blogs (I have a lot of free time at work) because the sportsmanship isn’t there. This goes for Jets blogs as well. I get mad at Pats fans dissing Jets, and calling all Jets fans Guidos, etc (which many are, mostly from NJ, while I am from Long Isl.), and saying we are lucky all the time, though we just keep winning. I also get annoyed at Jets fans who try to make it like we are the team to beat now in AFC East. Lets be real, until Pats fall off, its still your division, but we’re coming. I’m not trying to take the fun out of the rivalry, but the stupidity kills me. On a common note, I hate the Phins, and the Yankees, and I think Rex should shut up sometimes, though I do love him bc regardless of it all, he’s a great defensive coach, who does have a wining record against Pats. (p.s. prayers to people in VM affected by the hurricane)
by RealisticNYer on Sep 15, 2011 9:15 PM EDT up reply actions
I could see Brady with a +3 or a Zero
While he was certainly a difference maker, we have come to expect that. Though, outside of Brady, I don’t see too many other players caught in that circumstance.
watched most of belichick thing on nfl network stream...
him telling derrick mason to ‘f off’ when mason was talking trash made me lol
Bad things to come for nason
Ways do for those who talk s$&t to BB.
by gnatecolby on Sep 16, 2011 8:52 AM EDT via mobile up reply actions
Merriweather plus 2
No plus sign on phone sorry
He’s a plus because he is now someone elses liability in coverage. And his alleged rape in his home can be drama for Chicago not us. He would be a plus 3 if not for his replacements not lighting it up. Who was wearing 31 Monday as they had the dreads too. I kept thinking merriweather was taking correct angles…
by gnatecolby on Sep 16, 2011 8:51 AM EDT via mobile reply actions
Sergio Brown is 31 now I believe
Weird right? They look too much alike with the dreads and everything lol
Deep in enemy territory
First highlight I saw I thought "Wasn't he released? What did I miss overnight?"
"Perhaps it was the Noid who should have avoided me." Mayor Adam West
I'm still shocked he went to Chicago
In a Cover-2 D that occasionally will drop him to play Cover-1 or Cover-3, he has to be super-disciplined, stay in his zone, not wander, and make solid tackles.
Anyone want to take bets he’ll even do one of those things?
Token southern hemisphere guy - 14,688km from Foxboro. That's 9128 miles, for you heathens.
Contributing Writer at PatsPulpit
by Comedic.Sans on Sep 16, 2011 9:48 AM EDT up reply actions
Merriweather has some bad games but he may surprise people.
Most Pats fans seem to think Merriweather is a bad player. Chung will turn out better than M, but I’m not a hater on him and I think he’ll do well in Chicago. He lacked discipline, he’s not a team player and he sometimes hurts the team much like Asante did. But on the up side he brings strength to the backfield in hard hits we haven’t had since Harrison and the Bears like that kind of style.
by PatsFan13 on Sep 17, 2011 1:09 AM EDT up reply actions 1 recs
The Bears would also like a Safety they can trust to be deeper than the ball, too.
Not sure he can do that.
"Perhaps it was the Noid who should have avoided me." Mayor Adam West
He HAS to be deeper than the ball in a Cover/Tampa-2 D like the Bears run
If he comes up to the line and the ball goes over his head… the Bears are in soooo much trouble.
Token southern hemisphere guy - 14,688km from Foxboro. That's 9128 miles, for you heathens.
Contributing Writer at PatsPulpit
by Comedic.Sans on Sep 17, 2011 1:24 AM EDT up reply actions
Exactly. Cover-2 is simple but disciplined. You can’t free-lance. Ever.
by quadruple option on Sep 18, 2011 3:23 AM EDT up reply actions
Watch for Drew Brees to shred him a la 09.
"Perhaps it was the Noid who should have avoided me." Mayor Adam West

by 































