clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Will Patriots legend Adam Vinatieri be a first-ballot Hall of Famer?

Related: Adam Vinatieri is finally calling it a career

Super Bowl XXXVIII: New England Patriots Vs. Carolina Panthers Photo by Jim Davis/The Boston Globe via Getty Images

Adam Vinatieri’s career the stuff of legends. A former rookie free agent out of South Dakota State who had to spend a year in the NFL Europe before getting his shot in the “real” NFL, Vinatieri was the leader in numerous categories when he announced his retirement on Wednesday after 24 seasons in the league.

He is the all-time leading scorer (2,673 points), has played in more combined regular season and playoff games than anybody else (397), and holds multiple kicking records — from most field goals made (599), to most postseason points (238), to most consecutive field goals (44), to overtime field goals (12), among others. His list of accolades also includes four Super Bowl rings and spots on the NFL’s 100th anniversary team and Team of the 2000s.

As a result of all this, Vinatieri will be inducted in the New England Patriots and Pro Football Hall of Fames one day. When it comes to the latter, though, there is a question about timing: Will he make it in on first ballot in 2025, or will he have to wait?

Let’s try to figure out.

Why Adam Vinatieri will be a first-ballot Hall of Famer

As noted above, Vinatieri has posted some truly impressive statistics — statistics that exceed those posted by the only other exclusive place kickers enshrined in the Pro Football Hall of Fame, Jan Stenerud and Morten Andersen. While neither was a first-ballot selection, Vinatieri’s success in combination with his longevity gives him a much stronger case.

After all, he helped establish the Patriots’ dynasty in the early 2000s by making some of the biggest kicks in NFL history. His game-tying 45-yard field goal in the 2001 playoffs against the Raiders stands as arguably the greatest kick of all time, and helped the organization win its first Super Bowl — a game that was decided on another Vinatieri kick as time expired. He added two more titles before taking his talents to the Indianapolis Colts in 2006.

In Indianapolis, Vinatieri won yet another Super Bowl. Once again, his kicking played a pivotal role. That was especially true in the divisional round against Baltimore, when he made five field goals in a 15-6 victory.

While those numbers alone may not be first-ballot Hall of Fame worthy yet, the fact that he played for 24 seasons and is the only player to exceed 1,000 points with two different organizations helps him. The same goes for his status: no NFL Films highlight reel of the early 2000s is complete without mentioning Vinatieri’s contributions.

The fact is this: no kicker in NFL history has played as prominent a role, or made as many high-profile kicks as Vinatieri. It would therefore only be fitting if he became the first player at his position to enter the Hall of Fame without having to wait.

Why Adam Vinatieri will not be a first-ballot Hall of Famer

Richard Seymour, Tony Boselli, and Clay Matthews are already waiting for induction. Darrelle Revis, Vince Wilfork, Drew Brees, Philip Rivers, DeMarcus Ware, Dwight Freeney, Julius Peppers and Joe Thomas will be among a group of players set to become eligible over the coming years as well. Long story short, Vinatieri will face plenty of competition when it is his turn to enter the Hall of Fame in 2025.

The backlog of candidates in combination with the positional value of kickers (or special teamers in general) could put him in a difficult spot. The Hall of Fame is famously anti-special teamers — Steve Tasker would already be in if that were not the case — which in turn could mean that Vinatieri might have to wait a few years as well before eventually getting the call.

One also has to wonder whether or not his Pro Bowl and All-Pro nominations will be held against him by voters. He “only” made three each during his illustrious career, and was not recognized as an all-star in 21 of his 24 seasons. The Hall of Fame works in sometimes irrational-looking ways, and arguments could be made against inducting a player lacking those kinds of accolades on first ballot.

So, what will happen?

While kickers are underrepresented in the Pro Football Hall of Fame, and Vinatieri will face some challenging competition, the fact remains that he may very well be the greatest player his position has ever seen. He also has played a prominent role in establishing the lone dynasty of the NFL’s salary cap era, and has one highlight reel play after the other — something not every kicker, let alone Hall of Famer can say.

Is all of that enough to get him in on first ballot? It will be tough, and it would not be a surprise if the voters decided against it, but Vinatieri would certainly be deserving. His longevity and success clearly trump questions about positional value.

Poll

Will Adam Vinatieri make the Pro Football Hall of Fame on first ballot?

This poll is closed

  • 79%
    Yes.
    (430 votes)
  • 20%
    No.
    (108 votes)
538 votes total Vote Now